Strategic Perspectives

rmcguire by  rmcguire
Sprint Employee
Sprint Employee
31 

Mar 8, 2007
Currently Being Moderated

Pre or MiFi - which is more revolutionary 

Posted on Jun 15, 2009 | 8 Comments

In the past couple of weeks, Sprint has introduced two ground breaking products - the MiFi personal hotspot and the Palm Pre.  There's no question that each of these products is exciting and each advances the Mobility Revolution.  My question is, which do you think is the most revolutionary?

 

As a Sprint executive who speaks at conferences, I occasionally get to borrow some of our new technology to take with me to show off.  Recently, I was able to borrow the Sprint MiFi 2200 for a long weekend.   What an awesome device.  If you haven't seen it, here's how I would describe it: 

  • Take a deck of playing cards and cut the deck.  The half of the deck in your hand is rougly the size of the MiFi (but the MiFi is lighter).
  • Crammed into this tiny package is the functional equivalent of your broadband router connecting you to your cable or DSL provider, and your WiFi access point.  The MiFi provides broadband connectivity via Sprint's EV-DO network, and provides a WiFi signal for up to five devices (computers, media players, game machines, etc.)
  • Push the power button once, and within seconds you're connected.  That's simplicity!


Click here for a more thorough description.

 

As I drove around town, my son was able to surf the web at broadband speeds.  When we went into a restaurant for breakfast, we brought our own broadband connectivity with us.  In my office, I was able to connect my iPod Touch (which I won't connect to secure corporate networks) to download some updates.  At home, when my main broadband connection slowed down, I quickly switched to the MiFi and was back to full speed.

 

In short, because I was so blown away by this device, I asked for a MiFi of my own as my father's day present.

 

I also had the chance to borrow a test Pre for about a week and similarly had a life changing experience.

 

The most obvious difference with the Pre is the full HTML support.  E-mails on my phone now look like E-mails on my desk.  Web pages on my phone now look like Web pages on my desk.  The real upshot for me was that I was now getting things done while away from my desk that I previously had to save until I returned to the office.  That's increased productivity!

 

The synergy feature synchronizing e-mail, calendars, and contacts from my work Exchange server, my gmail personal account, and my online social networks, was also impressive.  At one glance, I could see how my personal calendar overlapped with my work calendar.  My one list of contacts combined info from all the sources without any effort.  I still chose to view my inboxes separately so I could focus on work stuff during work time, but switching between them was simple.

 

If demand weren't so high, I similarly would be standing in line for my own Pre today instead of writing this post.

 

To me, the Mobility Revolution is about Mobility being integrated into all of life - into every product, every service, and every process - to as dramatically change how we interact with the world and do our jobs as the Internet has impacted our lives.  

 

In those terms, each of these products is revolutionary.  But which do you think is more revolutionary?

Average user rating
(1 rating)
View blogosphere feedback
Bookmark and Share

Comments

Jun 15, 2009 9:57 PM quasijedi quasijedi 
Gold Expert
Gold Expert
  says:

Correct me if I'm wrong, Russ, but doesn't the MiFi use the Sprint EVDO network to connect to your WiFi device to the internet? And if so, doesn't that mean that the speed you would be getting on the MiFi could be no faster than simply using a USB dongle attached to a USB port on the same WiFi enabled device? I guess I'm trying to figure out why your EVDO card was giving you slower access speed than the MiFi. Seems like they should both provide nearly identical throughput since they are both accessing the same internet in the same way (only the MiFi then broadcasts that connection via WiFi so more than one device can be used simultaneously). So, to me, this is simply

 

As for the Pre, given the info I've read thus far...it seems to be light years better than the Instinct. But, since I have not used it for any extended length of time, I couldn't begin to judge it.

 

For me, neither really strikes me as being revolutionary or all that impressive. Just evolutionary, but that does not mean that neither are great products. To truly claim something is revolutionary, I'd say that the new widget for that Sprint has created is pretty revolutionary.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
Jun 15, 2009 10:00 PM Tomas Tomas 
Silver Expert
Silver Expert
  says:

I briefly played with the little WiFi router,and I believe it is revolutionary.

I'm typing this on a Palm Pre, and while I believe it will have a larger overall effect, it is more evolutionary.

The Pre combines a lot of SmartPhone features into one package, does it well, and has an excellent OS.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
Jun 16, 2009 6:38 PM rmcguire rmcguire 
Sprint Employee
Sprint Employee
  says:

Thanks for the comments.

 

quasijedi - I understand your confusion.  I said that I switched to the MiFi when my broadband connection became slow.  It is perfectly natural for you to assume that my primary broadband connection would also be Sprint's EVDO network.  However, at home, I have about a dozen IP devices hanging off of my WiFi network, so my main broadband connection has been from my cable provider.  The MiFi limits me to 5 WiFi connected devices, so I can't quite replace my cable broadband with EVDO via MiFi, but at least we're headed in the right direction.

 

The amazing thing to me was that, at times, the MiFi was faster than a broadband cable connection.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
Jun 22, 2009 9:17 AM OGbigMoneyMIKE OGbigMoneyMIKE 
Regular Visitor
Regular Visitor
  says:

I am canceling mt AT&T DSL after purchasing a Novatel Mi-Fi last week. It, to me, is truly revolutionary! I think its SO cool and it really is fast. I know Sprint in years past said they were faster than UMTS/HSDPA/HSUPA but in Los Angeles, it really wasnt the case, until now.

 

Im a prior Sprint PCS customer from the 1st day launch in Los Angeles who is happy to be back and escape the Oglopoly that Bush created in the 'new' AT&T.

Average user rating
(1 rating)

I am fortunate enough to own both the Pre and the MiFi.

 

The Pre is close to revolutionary, with the ability to truly multi-task, the excellent webOs, and other features. It needs only a few things to complete the package: 1. Better battery life. 2. More apps. 3. Better battery life. Although if you turn off wifi, bluetooth and always on location it helps. Also let the battery die totally a couple of times. It is an excellent phone. I also own the iPhone 3Gs (upgraded from original iPhone). I find myself trying to operate my iPhone like a Pre. A great complement to the Pre's UI.

 

The only problem with the MiFi is the 5GB limit. It is fast, sleek and oh so cool. If there was no limit, I would probably cancel my broadband connection. This is only my second mobile broadband device and my first through Sprint. My first was through Cricket, it is unlimited, but much slower. Perhaps Sprint could use their business model, full speed for 5GB the throttle back to 500kbps over 5GB for the month. Then it would truly be unlimited but would stop the small percentage that hog the majority of bandwidth. Something to think about and it would put Sprint ahead of the pack.

Average user rating
(1 rating)
Aug 19, 2009 9:49 AM Guest weasel   says in response to scottae316 :

I am disatisfied with my (rural) dsl speeds and have good Sprint coverage according to the map.  While at a mall I made a point to stop at the Sprint store to find out about broadband and if it weren't for the 5G limit, I would have signed up for a mifi on the spot and cancelled my dsl.  5G per month?  My kid downloaded a warcraft demo that was 4.6G alone.  Granted that's an occasional (but probably not exactly rare) occurrence, but it's obvious that a 5G limit is ridiculous these days for a home broadband replacement.  For a commuting laptop sure, but then you probably don't want to be sharing your connection with the entire bus/train or they'll use up your whole 5 gigabytes.

 

Anyway, I think scottae316's mention of Cricket's model would suit me fine.  After 5G throttle it back to 500Mbps, that's fine.  Heck throttle it back again after 10G or use a sliding scale to make it unattractive for bandwidth hogs or to keep someone from using it as a public hotspot.  Maybe eventually it slows to netzero dialup speeds at some point? :-)

 

The main thing is 5G is pretty tight for any sophisticated internet useage, and at >$60/month getting charged for an overage is not something I will risk -- nor can I have my broadband "turn off" during the month if we run over 5G.  I would be willing to pay the high (relative to cable/dsl) rate if it weren't for this cap.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
Aug 19, 2009 9:52 AM Guest weasel   says in response to weasel :

>  After 5G throttle it back to 500Mbps, that's fine.

 

(I meant to say throttle back to 500kbps of course)

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
Sep 6, 2009 2:09 PM Guest IntlSystems   says:

I agree that the MiFi is revolutionary. I would love to use it but the 5G limit scares me away from it. I'm afraid that some error or oversight will put me way over 5G and I will get an enormous bill. The billing is too open-ended. Weasel's idea of throttling throughput if use becomes excessive is much more palpable.

 

As for the Pre, I think Sprint is embarassing itself even offering it, let alone declaring it revolutionary. Do Sprint product planners look at the competition or did Sprint just get a batch of these things cheap because everyone else doesn't want them. I think it might appeal to existing Palm users who don't know any better. I tried it, I'll stick with my Mogul.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)

Welcome!

Sign up to connect with other people talking about the latest in wireless technology.

Sign in

I want to: