Samsung Moment

Original Post

53 Replies Last post - 3 months ago by latinmaxima
damasyork
Newbie
Newbie
3 posts since
Nov 16, 2009
Currently Being Moderated

Nov 17, 2009

Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet. 

Everyone suffering from what is being called horrible battery life on the Samsung Moment should read my experience with it:

I bought my Moment 10 days ago, and the first thing I noticed was the horrible battery life (to the tune of 4-5 hours-- and that is 4-5 hrs. of STANDBY not talk time as it should be).  After taking the phone off the charger, the battery indicator would show 80% within minutes, then 60% after 15 minutes, then down to 15% within a couple hours.  I started scouring posts regarding battery issues hoping to get a solution because I really liked the phone and didn't want to return it. Most users reported similar battery issues, some claimed to see improvement with certain "fixes", but most agreed that the Moment has horrible battery life or at least a seriously faulty battery indicator. A couple Moment owners, however, reported excellent battery life (36 hours with moderate use!).

After going through about 150-200 posts both on the Android blog and on the Sprint discussion board, I compiled all the recipes and fixes proposed by users. I then tried all of those recipes:

-  Disabling GPS, Bluetooth, WiFi, no video playing, etc.: This kind of defeats the purpose of owning a smart phone, but I still did it.  Still, the phone died after a few hours just on standby and a few minutes of talk time!

-  Battery conditioning (the fully-charge-battery-then-fully-drain-it-and-repeat-several-times method): After doing this for five consecutive days, there was little improvement. The phone still died after 6-7 hours with little use and with GPS, bluetooth and WiFi off!

-  I downloaded Taskiller: I used it very often to kill all running apps. That didn't work (and some applications restarted themselves immediately after being killed).

-  Assuming that the problem was with a power-hungry third-party application that was running in the background, I did a factory reset and then deleted all widgets on the home screen (the ones that shipped with the phone: Weather, NFL, TV).  That didn't improve the battery life either.

I was about to take the phone back to Sprint, yesterday, when SOMETHING INCREDIBLE happened:  I took the phone off the charger at 10 a.m.,  enabled GPS and bluetooth and started using the phone casually expecting it to die after a few hours like it did in each of the previous 8 days.  But after three hours (when the battery used to be down to 60%), the indicator still showed 100%. I was shocked!

As I am typing this, it has been 32 hours since the last charge and the battery status is at 40%. I made a few phone calls yesterday and today, browsed quite a few web pages, used Google maps, exchanged several text messages, checked my email a few times.  This means the battery life is as good or even better than the specifications and the reviews say.

I am still in shock and very curious to know what happened yesterday. So what happened?  Yesterday was the first time I charge the phone from my computer with the USB cable. Could that have been the magic potion?  Also yesterday, for the first time I implemented the following tips suggested by SarahKS (a Sprint Administrator):

- Turn off data and voice call roaming

- Turn off Auto-Sync for Google applications

- Turn off Window Animations

At any rate, there is one fact that cannot be denied:  The trouble that I and others had with the battery can be resolved, and Samsung should get to work on this issue immediately. The bottom line: The Samsung Moment ranks at the top of smart phones when it comes to battery life! 

Average user rating
(1 rating)
Bookmark and Share

Replies

wengla02
Sprint Admin
Sprint Admin
3,376 posts since
Nov 1, 2006
Currently Being Moderated
1. Nov 17, 2009 Posted in response to: damasyork
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

Sarah - how's yours doing?

 

Seems odd that charging off a USB port in the computer would give better battery life, unless it's because it's a slower charge.  Most PC usb ports only provide 500ma, while the charger is 800ma.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
latinmaxima
Valued Member
Valued Member
83 posts since
Jan 6, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
2. Nov 18, 2009 Posted in response to: wengla02
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

The USB charge does take longer but it definitely seems to help the phone last longer. I charge with the wall charger at night and then top of with the usb when I get to work. It lasts nearly two full days easily now. I use it all day long whether emails or web or games and texts and calls both with BT and just the phone. This is by far the best phone I have ever used!

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
aBsTRaCt
Sprint Employee
Sprint Employee
68 posts since
Nov 17, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
3. Nov 19, 2009 Posted in response to: latinmaxima
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

@latinmaxima - does your battery appear to report correctly?  I've noticed my battery life has significantly increased since i first got the phone, but the reporting is sporadic at best.  I hold for 4-5 hours at 15% - and tonight it hovered between3-5% for about 5 hours (2 x 20 minute phone calls and medium use during that time).

 

I ran it dead and i'll try the trickle charge method tonight.  We'll see what happens.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
Stoney62
Regular Visitor
Regular Visitor
11 posts since
Nov 10, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
4. Nov 20, 2009 Posted in response to: damasyork
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

I too am suddenly getting 36 hours plus. Not doing the tips that Sarah suggests. Like you said what's a smartphone worth buying for without using the stuff. But I did do the full charge a couple times with the USB.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
JennA
Newbie
Newbie
2 posts since
Nov 20, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
5. Nov 20, 2009 Posted in response to: damasyork
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

Thank you for your post. We just purchased 3 moment's and have had them 2 days. We had read about the battery life and were hoping there is a way to improve it because we too like the phones. I am hopeful that the charger is the solution to the problem. I may have sent my phone back without having found your post. I have mine plugged into the USB right now, so wish us  luck!

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
DavidAG92
Regular Visitor
Regular Visitor
8 posts since
Oct 8, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
6. Nov 22, 2009 Posted in response to: JennA
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

I am experiencing a longer battery life after having the phone nearly 20 days. Some improvement is seen when I don't keep it on auto-sync. I try to keep killing unused apps as well as following the other advise when possible. It seems that the usb cable charge may be an interesting remedy.

David

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
JennA
Newbie
Newbie
2 posts since
Nov 20, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
7. Nov 23, 2009 Posted in response to: JennA
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

Charging with the USB did it for me. My phone lasted from 8am yesterday to 9pm tonight with pretty good usage, and even though the battery said 15% at 6pm it still made it through an hour on the phone from 8-9 (being used as a baby monitor). Great phone. I hope that it improves a little more, but it's enough for me to keep it.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
jeffcj
Regular Visitor
Regular Visitor
6 posts since
Nov 20, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
8. Nov 23, 2009 Posted in response to: JennA
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

I find it strange that the lower powered (500mA if memory serves) charge provided by the USB port seems to be providing a better charge than the AC charger.  Defect in the charging circuit somewhere perhaps?

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
jwalker55
Regular Visitor
Regular Visitor
33 posts since
Nov 23, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
9. Nov 23, 2009 Posted in response to: JennA
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

Charging through USB should make zero difference.  Putting the battery through a few full cycles should help the phone calibrate the battery meter so it is a bit more accurate.  The capacity of a lithium ion battery will be at it's max right when it leaves the factory and shortly after.  Pretty much the second it leaves the factory, it begins losing capacity, which is roughly 20% per year.  This is the reason lithium ion batteries generally only have a usable life cycle of a couple years.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
themightyelf
Regular Visitor
Regular Visitor
6 posts since
Nov 23, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
10. Nov 24, 2009 Posted in response to: jeffcj
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

>>I find it strange that the lower powered (500mA if memory serves) charge provided by the USB port seems to be providing a better charge than the AC charger.  Defect in the charging circuit somewhere perhaps?

 

I have rechargeable AA batteries at home along with a quick charger, charges the battery in about 30 minutes, and a slow-trickle charger, charges it to full capacity in a few hours.  Trickle-charged batteries seem to last longer than the quick-charged ones.  I'm no electrical engineer, but my guess is that the lower current used by the trickle charges allows it to give the batttery a more "full" charge.

 

Maybe this explains why charging the Moment using the lower current USB charger leaves the battery with more power than charging with the wall charger?

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
numus
Regular Visitor
Regular Visitor
28 posts since
Nov 24, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
11. Nov 24, 2009 Posted in response to: themightyelf
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

Heat is your main enemy with charging batteries.. The hotter the battery gets, the less actual amperage it is able to hold...

 

To dumb down the reasoning.. Think of V = IR where V is the target voltage of the battery pack that the phone is charging at... Resistance(R) is a constant so the only unknown is current (I)...  V/R = I.. if resistance is held at a constant then the way the battery charges is V = I so when the voltage hits the target you know you have the correct current (amps) in the battery...

BUT when a battery or any other cell heats up.. R = R(o)*(1+alpha(T-T(0)) meaning Resistance is temperature dependent.. the higher T gets from original temperature (T(0)) the larger the resistance gets

Since Resistance is indirectly proportionate to current (I) the larger R gets the small I gets... If you go back to V(Target) = I(1) and V(Target) = I(2)R you will notice that V(1) (target voltage) remains teh same

so I(1) = I(2)R... I(1)/R = I(2)... if resistance increases the current that the phone thinks is full actually decreases...

One thing you have to know is the battery meter is actually determining the voltage of the cell.. Not the current in the cell (since current meters need to be installed in series and have to have a theoretical resistance close to 0 which is near impossible).. So what you see in the meter is a representation on what the voltage of the battery is

 

Basically all i proved and demonstrated is that if temperature increases, the battery will absorb less actual current and still think the battery is full based upon the Voltage it reads.. When the battery cools this voltage decreases as resistance decreases

 

When you use a rapid charger, it heats up the battery because it is pumping more current through the battery faster... when you use a slower trickle charge it keeps temperature more stable as it charges...

 

Message was edited by: numus

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
themightyelf
Regular Visitor
Regular Visitor
6 posts since
Nov 23, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
12. Nov 25, 2009 Posted in response to: numus
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

numus wrote:

 

Heat is your main enemy with charging batteries.. The hotter the battery gets, the less actual amperage it is able to hold...

 

To dumb down the reasoning.. Think of V = IR where V is the target voltage of the battery pack that the phone is charging at... Resistance(R) is a constant so the only unknown is current (I)...  V/R = I.. if resistance is held at a constant then the way the battery charges is V = I so when the voltage hits the target you know you have the correct current (amps) in the battery...

BUT when a battery or any other cell heats up.. R = R(o)*(1+alpha(T-T(0)) meaning Resistance is temperature dependent.. the higher T gets from original temperature (T(0)) the larger the resistance gets

Since Resistance is indirectly proportionate to current (I) the larger R gets the small I gets... If you go back to V(Target) = I(1) and V(Target) = I(2)R you will notice that V(1) (target voltage) remains teh same

so I(1) = I(2)R... I(1)/R = I(2)... if resistance increases the current that the phone thinks is full actually decreases...

One thing you have to know is the battery meter is actually determining the voltage of the cell.. Not the current in the cell (since current meters need to be installed in series and have to have a theoretical resistance close to 0 which is near impossible).. So what you see in the meter is a representation on what the voltage of the battery is

 

Basically all i proved and demonstrated is that if temperature increases, the battery will absorb less actual current and still think the battery is full based upon the Voltage it reads.. When the battery cools this voltage decreases as resistance decreases

 

When you use a rapid charger, it heats up the battery because it is pumping more current through the battery faster... when you use a slower trickle charge it keeps temperature more stable as it charges...

 

Message was edited by: numus

 

So is it correct to assume that the Moment wall charger is akin to my using the rapid charger on my AA batteries while charging using the USB cable similar to my trickle charger?  Does the wall charger pump more current compared to the USB?  If that's the case, then this explains why charging using the wall charger gets you to only 80% of full charge quickly (the most the battery can absorb given it's temperature) and why the USB charger can take care of the remaining 20% (lower battery charging temperature leading to more ability to absorb current).

 

Does this mean we need wall chargers that pump less current into the battery?  (May take longer to charge, but at least we know the phone will truly be 100% charged upon unplugging.) 

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
jwalker55
Regular Visitor
Regular Visitor
33 posts since
Nov 23, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
13. Nov 25, 2009 Posted in response to: themightyelf
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

themightyelf wrote:

 

numus wrote:

 

Heat is your main enemy with charging batteries.. The hotter the battery gets, the less actual amperage it is able to hold...

 

To dumb down the reasoning.. Think of V = IR where V is the target voltage of the battery pack that the phone is charging at... Resistance(R) is a constant so the only unknown is current (I)...  V/R = I.. if resistance is held at a constant then the way the battery charges is V = I so when the voltage hits the target you know you have the correct current (amps) in the battery...

BUT when a battery or any other cell heats up.. R = R(o)*(1+alpha(T-T(0)) meaning Resistance is temperature dependent.. the higher T gets from original temperature (T(0)) the larger the resistance gets

Since Resistance is indirectly proportionate to current (I) the larger R gets the small I gets... If you go back to V(Target) = I(1) and V(Target) = I(2)R you will notice that V(1) (target voltage) remains teh same

so I(1) = I(2)R... I(1)/R = I(2)... if resistance increases the current that the phone thinks is full actually decreases...

One thing you have to know is the battery meter is actually determining the voltage of the cell.. Not the current in the cell (since current meters need to be installed in series and have to have a theoretical resistance close to 0 which is near impossible).. So what you see in the meter is a representation on what the voltage of the battery is

 

Basically all i proved and demonstrated is that if temperature increases, the battery will absorb less actual current and still think the battery is full based upon the Voltage it reads.. When the battery cools this voltage decreases as resistance decreases

 

When you use a rapid charger, it heats up the battery because it is pumping more current through the battery faster... when you use a slower trickle charge it keeps temperature more stable as it charges...

 

Message was edited by: numus

 

So is it correct to assume that the Moment wall charger is akin to my using the rapid charger on my AA batteries while charging using the USB cable similar to my trickle charger?  Does the wall charger pump more current compared to the USB?  If that's the case, then this explains why charging using the wall charger gets you to only 80% of full charge quickly (the most the battery can absorb given it's temperature) and why the USB charger can take care of the remaining 20% (lower battery charging temperature leading to more ability to absorb current).

 

Does this mean we need wall chargers that pump less current into the battery?  (May take longer to charge, but at least we know the phone will truly be 100% charged upon unplugging.)

 

Most USB wall chargers can charge at 1 A, whereas your standard USB port will only allow a max of 500 mA, so charging via a USB port on your computer should be slower.  Without looking at the charger, I would assume it's a 1 amp charger like most others.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)
Dolijr
Regular Visitor
Regular Visitor
8 posts since
Nov 23, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
14. Nov 25, 2009 Posted in response to: damasyork
Re: Hold on, folks! Don't give up on the Moment's battery yet.

I don't know if I am the only one. I have tried all these things. I am used to a blackberry where with heavy use I could get at least a full work day, that was if I was roaming all day and wrote more then 50 emails and 100 text messages. Now i can get almost to noon. I have had the phone for just about a week. Turning of the sync features just isn't a choice for me. I have to get my emails. I use the Gmail one and set up a different one as well.

 

I have let my phone turn off every day for the last week and have charged it by usb twice. Like this morning I did that and took it off the charger at 8 am it is now 9 am and I am down to 80%. No phone calls this morning, just a few emails and text messages received. I have the alternative email syncing every 30 minutes. I have GPS turned off, but I do use my bluetooth all the time. I use wi-fi whenever I am home or in the office, which is pretty much all the time.

 

I am very irritated. So far except for turning off all the options and just using it as a phone I am thinking about going back to blackberry. I will the usb charging for a couple more times, but the whole 30 day thing really has be in a hurry.

 

I really love this phone, but the battery thing is killing me.

Average user rating
(0 ratings)

Welcome!

Sign up to connect with other people talking about the latest in wireless technology.

Sign in

I want to:

More like this

  • Retrieving data ...