My wife needs a new phone and was wondering if I should go with a HTC Touch or an Instinct ( or possibly a Centro? ). Im interested in hearing from folks that have experience with both on:
- Touch sensitivity ( how easy to text message . Responsiveness to touches - do they indicate a selection was made well? )
- Signal Reception ( She currently has signal probs with RAZR V3m at work, are these any better? )
- UI Speed ( How quick to find contacts and dial, Anything frustratingly slow )
- Call Reliability ( Anything odd about answering / placing a call. Does it crash once in a while? )
- MP3 playing
- Battery Life
- Camera quality ( I know most cell cameras are terrible, which is slightly better? )
Any little bit of info would help greatly! Thank you for your time!
I just (last week on 6/22/2008) swapped in my RAZR V3m for a Samsung Instinct. I went back and forth on whether to get the Instinct or the HTC Touch. My coworker has had an HTC touch for a few weeks so I had been toying around with it, but I didn't really like the touch sensitivity and I am not a huge fan of Microsoft Mobile OS. I have heard good and bad (through online reviews) on the Instinct, but I went to the store and checked it out for myself. In the end, I purchased the Instinct online via the Sprint store and it arrived within 2 days. I am loving it, but it is not perfect. In terms of your questions, let me answer them first:
Overall, the Instinct is easier to use than the Touch. It has great call volume and the speakerphone works really well. The Internet browser is really fast (for a mobile phone). It's really easy to sync e-mail with the majors (Yahoo, Google, AOL). I was surprised at how easy it was to sync up with my work e-mail (Outlook Exchange). You should also check out theInstinct'sGPSnavigationfeatures. I was thinking about getting a GPS system for my car this year and now I don't have to shell out the money for it because it's in my phone. I have yet to regret my decision for going with this phone. There is a great site called www.phonedog.com that reviews all aspects of this phone and the Touch as well. If you are going to stick with Sprint, I say the Instinct is the way to go.
So now that I spoke of the good of Instinct, here are some of the cons that you may want to consider (they may not be important to you or your wife):
Good luck on making your decision. I hope my comments helped. Feel free to ask any others and I'll try to be as helpful as possible. You seem a lot like me in terms of trying to make an informed buying decision based on the feedback of others.
Thank you very much for your information!!! We really appreciate the time you spent writing that for us!
We went to the Sprint store armed with a printout of your information and were able to compare two working demos side-by-side. We liked the Instinct for some things (Haptic touch, Media, Responsiveness) and the Touch for others (calendar sync, seemed smaller/lighter). Sadly, after a long argument with the CSR they told us we would have to abandon our ten year old shared phone plan pricing on all of our phones if we were to get an Instinct. However, buying a HTC touch phone wouldnt have any impact on our contract / pricing.
The worst part is we got pretty hyped up about the Instinct to be let down at the store with the terms of obtaining one. Mostly my fault for thinking there had to be another way to get the phone without the "Everything" plan.
I just switched from the touch to the instinct and I like the instinct a lot better. touching is easier, cameras are about what what, neither has a flash. reception is good on both phones.
Wow, that is a great amount of good information. Thanks for taking the time to post that as it was very helpful! I have two things that I am worried about when it comes to making a choice on either phone:
1. First I have been noticing that Instinct owners have problems with their calendar feature. They state that their calendar does not allow them to save more events and displays a "no more space" type of message. I would be very relient on the calendar as that would be how I would mainly want to organize my time and plans. It seems that the HTC Touch has the Windows style calendar, that many PDAs contain and this would work very well.
2. The music feature would be another feature that I am interested in with either phone. The only upset is the fact that the HTC Touch does not contain a headset jack so you can plug in headphones or connect it to a car stereo to listen to music. If I am not incorrect you would only be able to use bluetooth technology to listen to songs. Is that accurate?
So I was wondering if I should not even worry about the music portion of the phones and just get an Apple Ipod Classic to remedy the situation and just listen to music that way. It can hold much more memory and connect to a car stereo easily. The only downside is the fact that you are not able to used bluetooth to listen to music.