YES! I have the exact same issues. It stinks. Apparently about a third of us users hold the phone a certain way, and we get to explore the options offered on the screen while we're on calls!
I need help with this, the CL14 update didn't fix it. I don't want to always use my speakerphone. I don't always want to use a headset. Sprint, help us! On important calls now, I have to tell people...."if you can't hear me, don't hang up, say something and I'll check to see if you're muted."
Going to change my signature on emails to "Sent via Google Android...the phone that does everything well, except the phone part."
I do not take the phone away from my face. this occurs with normal movement while the phone is to my ear - I do not move it away from my ear. do I keep it perfectly still probally not, but just normal talking. I had the instict prior and this issue never came up for me.
i'm a little late here, but I want to throw in my 2 cents. the only time i have a problem with my prox sensor is when i get a text message when i am on a call. the darn notification lights up the screen and, since my head is already next to the prox sensor, it doesn't realise that it needs to turn off. that is when i start muting and speakering calls. I've tried the stock message app and handcent, and still have the problem, so unfortuately I do not have any kind of solution to offer.
The CL14 update made no inhancment to the proximity sensor so that will not change the way it operates. It was mentioned in an earlier post that a screen protector was casuing the issue. Do you users having the issue have screen protectors on your device? Is it covering the proximity sensor? The fact that you've had two device and they both exhibit the same "failure" of the sensor leads me to think that it's more of user error than a defect in the device as there are many users not experiencing this "failure" including myself.
I have not experienced this problem. However, I just played around with the position of the phone and may have duplicated what you are seeing.
Normally, I hold the speaker (i.e. the part of the phone that says Sprint) very close to my ear. The body of the phone is parallel to my face. The display will turn on if the phone is rotated so the microphone (i.e. the part of the phone by the end button) is close to my mouth and the bottom of the phone is parallel to my chin. This kicks the proximity sensor (i.e. the top part of the phone) away from any part of my face. This is not at all a natural position for me but might be for you.
Have you tried to move the phone around to different positions to see how the screen reacts? Give a good two seconds after each position to allow for the phone to react. The two second delay is on purpose and prevents the phone display from 'accidentally' turning on if it is temporarily repositioned.
I have no problems with prox sensor and my was reporting the same as people who were complaining. I have a feeling it has to do with either the shape of ear/head/face or the way the phone is held.
Have you all tried holding the phone different ways just to test?
It might just be like the Coolpix cameras that always asked if someone blinked when it took a picture of someone from Asian lineage, it doesnt handle all body types very well.
I have tried and have to be sooooo careful so the screen does not turn on. I think that the sensor may not be in the greatest spot - the phone is very wide and people are going to hold in in various positions for comfort. If the sensor was closer to the center (not toward the left) I bet this wouldn't even be an issue. I have had touchscreens in the past, this is the first phone where I have had any kind of issue.
The Palm Pre was the first device that Sprint carried with a Proximity Sensor and that was less then a year ago. It's still a ways away from being perfected. Maybe a setting to allow you to manually lock the touchscreen while on call like the old touch screen devices were.... I could see a market app or SW update enabling that function would be very usefull for users with this "issue"...
I have this same issue with the Proximity Sensor. I was on the phone call with someone and then I heard the phone ringing. I pull the phone away from my ear and it was 3 way calling someone else. How embarassing! Not only that but I would accidently put people on speaker or mute or hang up on them. Other than that I started accessing applications & playing music on my phone. Going to take it to the store tomorrow & see what they can do. Its retarded!
It is terrible, you can't even use the phone. Anyway you are not alone. I have read customer reviews of this phone and yes tons of people are having the same issue. Hopefully they can come up with a fix. Maybe create an app with a better sensor or an app to lock the screen. Anything would be great. I do love this phone (except for calls), I just wish this problem could be solved.
I've only owned 2 cell phones. 1st was an Instinct which I liked. Then I bought a Moment
and I'm having huge trouble with the proximity sensor. I constantly launch apps with my face.
If my phone is out in the open and I receive a call, The display lights up then the screen blanks out,
I press the call button to answer call and the display turns on again but the call doesn't connect so I need to hit the call
again before the answering machine kicks in. I thought it was operator error but it obviously is a technical issue.
I had the same problem and still do some of the time. If you hold the phone lower so that the top part sits sort of in the ear instead of over the top of the ear (like my old phone), it helps quite a bit.
I think the tilt detection is also part of the problem since it also unlocks/activates the screen.. at least, that's been my experiece.
Hopefully they fix some of it in the upcoming update, but I wouldnt count on it.
Heres to hope though!